A person can face charges at the federal and state level for the same illegal gun crime but they could face substantially different penalties at both levels of government.

Alfonso Gambone
Connect with me
A Philadelphia criminal defense attorney representing accused persons throughout Pennsylvania and New Jersey.

Our firm represents a number of individuals charged or indicted under federal law with the illegal possession of a firearm because of their status as a “prohibited person”. It is important to understand that a person can face charges at the federal and state level for the same incident or crime but that they could face substantially different penalties at both of these levels of government.


Pennsylvania and New Jersey Gun Laws – Prohibited Persons Offenses


In Pennsylvania, a person violates the Commonwealth’s Uniform Firearms Act under Section 6105 when a person possesses a firearm despite his/her status which disqualifies them from possession. These are otherwise known as enumerated offenses and are detailed further within the statute but they include crimes of violence (murder, manslaughter, aggravated assault, burglary, robbery), as well as offenses or crimes under Pennsylvania’s Controlled Substance, Device, and Cosmetic Act, along with similar federal or other state statutes.


A person also commits an offense under Section 6105 if they are the subject of an active protection from abuse order or they have previously been adjudicated delinquent under the juvenile system. In most situations, a violation of Section 6105 is a felony of the 2nd degree but there are situations where it is a misdemeanor offense (protection from abuse order).


New Jersey maintains a very similar statute under its Graves Act offense.  Unlike Pennsylvania, however, the Garden State gun offense typically carry with them mandatory minimum sentences.  The Garden State maintains a prohibited person statute under 2C: 39-7, like Pennsylvania (18 § 6105). In New Jersey a person who has been convicted in the state or any other jurisdiction, including Pennsylvania, of Aggravated Assault, a violent felony such as Homicide, Endangering the Welfare of a Child, and certain drug offenses such as the leader of a narcotics network (2C: 35-3), Maintaining or Operating a Production Facility (2C: 35-4), and Manufacturing, Distributing, or Dispensing a Controlled Substance (2C: 35-5), is prohibited from possessing a firearm and commits a crime of the second degree if he or she does so. Remember that in New Jersey a crime of the second degree carries with it a presumption of incarceration in state prison, whereas crimes of the 3rd and 4th degree do not carry this presumption.


Federal Prohibited Persons Offenses - 18 USC § 922(g)


Under 18 USC § 922(g) a person faces up to 10 years in federal prison if he/she possesses a firearm (gun) or ammunition and falls into any of the following categories:


  • Felon—this would include a person awaiting trial on felony charges
  • Drug user or addict—federal prosecution can demonstrate this through paraphernalia seized, positive drug test, and/or claims drugs were for personal use
  • Alien—this includes illegal aliens and aliens lawfully admitted under non-immigrant visas
  • A person who is subject to a domestic restraining order (PFA)
  • A person with a prior conviction for domestic assault
  • A fugitive from justice
  • Dishonorably discharge from the military


 It is important to keep in mind that the possession of a firearm by this prohibited person is not enough to prosecute under Section 922 but rather the prosecution must demonstrate that the firearm or ammunition was transported across state lines at some point in time.


 At the state level, in Pennsylvania for example, under Section 6105, a prohibited person commits a felony of the 2nd degree and sentencing guidelines place the offense at an offense gravity score of 10, which subjects even a first time offender to a potential state prison sentence with sentencing guidelines of 22-36 months.


Federal Sentencing Guidelines and Prohibited Persons Firearm Offenses


At the federal level however, the offense gravity score is based on the type of weapon (i.e. semi-automatic—capable of accepting a large capacity magazine) and the number of convictions within the person’s criminal history. At the high end, the base offense level score is a 26 where a person possesses a semi-automatic weapon and has at least 2 prior felony convictions of either a crime of violence or a controlled substance offense which includes state convictions. A 26 base offense level score will carry with it sentencing guidelines of 63-78 months which could increase based on the status of the weapon: stolen—increased by 2 levels; if the weapon had an altered or obliterated serial number—increased by 4 levels (a separate offense in Pennsylvania, Section 6110.1-felony of the 2nd degree).  Federal Judges however, are bound by sentencing guidelines and I encourage you to read my article on federal sentencing to understand more about this issue



What You Should Do Next If You or a Friend Are Charged With a “prohibited person” gun offense


At the federal and state level, a person charged with these offenses obviously face a substantial exposure and their attorney must determine the best course of action which should include a review of reasonable suspicion and probable cause to stop, search, and arrest the individual. In addition to pre-trial strategy, trial strategy should include actual vs. constructive possession arguments.


For more information on gun crimes in Pennsylvania and at the federal level, I encourage you to contact our office and visit our free download section.

Be the first to comment!
Post a Comment